The Alphastream Game Design Blog

The D&D Fan’s Guide to Buying the New Magic the Gathering Forgotten Realms Set

Magic the Gathering will finally have a card set devoted to D&D! This has many D&D fans wondering: what is the best way to pick up the cool cards? I spoke to Dave Chalker, an extraordinary game designer with deep expertise in both chocolate and peanut butter (I think D&D is the chocolate… I forgot to ask Dave).

About the Set

If you haven’t been following the news, this is a full MtG set with all the trimmings. We have foil cards, alternate art, special lands, new mechanics, and more! With this comes a ton of advertising across both the D&D and MtG channels. The set is available everywhere MtG are sold, including on the digital platform, Magic the Gathering Arena.

The set is looking to be really popular, and the card previews look amazing. If you don’t mind spoilers, you can find previews of all the cards on the WotC site here. Awesome folks like Mike Balles have been sharing previews on Twitter. And, Dave Chalker will be streaming the digital cards as they hit Arena, all on the Critical Hits Twitch channel and the Critical Hits YouTube channel.

The idea of a D&D / Magic the Gathering (MtG) crossover has been on fans’ minds for a very long time. WotC staff on both teams have tried over the years to get this to happen… and the time has finally come. It’s a tremendous opportunity for both brands to grow. And I’m hearing a lot of excitement by D&D fans. The wide appeal and covid may make this hard to collect. WotC is already warning of shortfalls due to covid shipping impacts and increased demand as stores open up.

The set releases on July 8th digitally and physically on July 23rd. You can preorder physical products, and should if you want lots of cards.

Overview and Free Adventures

You can find an overview of the products below, and also here. The card art is amazing, covering all kinds of aspects of D&D and the Forgotten Realms (and even Mordenkainen from Greyhawk). Some cards have alternate art evocative of early products, some have art that covers the whole card, and we even get land cards that look like classic module covers!

Speaking of adventures, five free adventures are being released with the set, one each week! As of this writing, In Scarlet Flames and The Hidden Page have been released. Both are by Will Hindmarch, an excellent adventure designer.

Card art by Wayne Reynolds… and Erol Otus?!!!

Identifying Your Goals

Before you start buying, figure out what you want out of this set.

  • Do you just want a few playable decks, so you can try out Magic?
  • Do you want a fair number of cards so you can build your own decks?
  • Do you want a relatively small number of cards to admire or use as inspiration for D&D games?
  • Do you want a lot of cards, maybe even all of them, to collect?

Knowing your goals will help you shop efficiently.

What to Buy

Once you know your general goals, it’s time to decide between paper or digital (or both). I’m going to primarily focus on the physical paper products. MtG apparently doesn’t have MSRP (suggested retail prices), so I’m providing prices I found online – they may vary! Also, most sites will have a maximum number of copies you can buy to prevent reselling and hoarding. Smaller stores and even popular stores may already be out of stock even during the preorder phase.

Physical Cards and Products

Commander Decks

These four decks are a great way to get playable decks and an intro to the Forgotten Realms set. Each deck is created to be a fun experience, and the four decks all play well together. You get 100 cards in each deck, including 2 legendary foil cards, a foil-etched commander card (which boosts your deck in some way), 10 double-sided tokens, a life wheel, and the deck box. If you just want to be able to play, this is a great buy.

These Commander Decks feature two-to-three colors, meaning a single deck won’t provide a sampling of all the colors. Buying all four will give you that wider experience.

Price: Around $130-150 for all four decks, or about $35 each.

Set Booster Boxes

If you are a D&D minis collector, you might know that with minis you can buy a case and get every mini in the set. This is not at all how Magic works. For example, about 10% of Set and Draft boosters contain a rare or mythic rare with an alternate art treatment. This means that collecting a full set is very hard.

If your goal is to buy most or all of the cards, your best bet is to pick up 1-2 Set Boosters, which are boxes of booster packs including art cards and other collectible cards beyond game cards. Each booster pack could have multiple rares in each (you get at least 1, but up to 4 is possible). You can then see what you are missing and pick up the single cards you need. A booster box has 30 packs of 12 cards each, for a total of 360 cards (you of course will end up with some duplicates and lots of cards you still don’t have, since cards have various rarities). You can get a Vorpal Sword promo card buying a box of set booster boxes at your FLGS (this also applies to Draft and Collectors boxes mentioned below).

Price: Around $120-130 per box.

Draft Booster Boxes

This box holds 36 packs of 15 cards each. More cards, but the intention of these cards is to support drafting, where players take turns opening packs, choosing a card, and passing the pack around. These packs are less suited for collecting.

Price: Around $115-140 per box.

Collector Booster Boxes

Expensive! You get only 12 packs in a box, but each pack of 15 cards has 5 Rare or Mythic Rare cards. These can be a great way to just get cool cards… at a price.

Price: Around $245-280 per box.


This large box is a pretty cardboard box to store your cards. It also comes with 10 booster packs, 1 foil alternate art promo card (Treasure Chest), 3 oversized dungeon cards, 40 basic land cards (20 foil), and an oversized d20 with the set logo.

This is mainly a fun purchase. If you play, the oversized dungeon cards are a nice feature, since you normally place the dungeon cards out in the open and refer to them. Larger cards provide utility and look cool. And, I mean… it comes with a d20! Oh, and there will be a second slightly different version released in August.

Price: Around $45-60.

Individual Booster Packs

You can always drop by your FLGS and pick up an individual normal booster pack ($4 or so) or a collector’s booster pack ($25 or so).

You can also pick up Theme Boosters, which are tailored to one mana color. Each has 1-2 rares or mythic rares and 33-34 commons and uncommons.

Dungeon cards! Click to see the large version.

Arena Digital Cards

If you play on Arena, there are two bundles worth considering. The Lolth Pack Bundle grants you sleeve decorations, 50 packs, and a special Lolth card. The Ellywick Play Bundle offers sleeve decorations, a dragon pet, tokens, a Mastery Pass, and Ellywick Tumblestrum cards.

I hope this has been helpful! If you have tips for buying and collecting, share them below! And, once the set releases, tell us about your favorite card.

7 comments on “The D&D Fan’s Guide to Buying the New Magic the Gathering Forgotten Realms Set

  1. Richard Green
    July 8, 2021

    This is really helpful Teos! I escaped Magic’s clutches a long time ago but I can feel myself being drawn in again. Sounds like one or two commander decks is a good place to start.

    • Alphastream
      July 8, 2021

      Thanks! It’s an excellent place to start. With 2 decks you and a friend can play and drool over the cool art. I am super-excited about this set. I briefly collected in the late ’90s, and it is dangerously fun!

      • Marty
        July 11, 2021

        Hey Teos,
        This is hugely helpful. I didn’t realize the differences between draft boosters, regular boosters, and collector ones.

        You might want to note the small difference between the d20 sets. One comes with a regular size d20 (red/orange), but the “gift set” is the oversize purple d20, if I remember correctly.

  2. Brian King
    October 29, 2021

    OK, so I am waaaayyy behind here. I don’t play MTG. My friends do, my cousins do, and my nephews do. But, as a huge Realms fan since day one, I am feeling strangely compelled to buy / collect these, and maybe even learn to play. I am disappointed to hear it’s not like buying minis by the case and getting everything, but this was really helpful. Sounds like I would want to start with a Collector Booster Box. If my goal is a full set, and was willing to spend a stupid amount of cash (it’s that SAP consulting money, Teos!), would I be better off buying two Collector Boosters or only one of those and one Set Booster Box or something like that?

    • Alphastream
      October 29, 2021

      Define “stupid!” Ha-ha. Throwing money at Magic is like throwing water on sand… So, if you buy one Collector Booster Box and two Set Booster Boxes, you will have close to a full set. Part of the problem is that each type of box has different ratios of cards. For example, there is a type of card that is best through the Collector Booster Box, but has low rarity. Other types are in Set Booster.

      If you want a full set of the normal numbered cards, and don’t care as much for art and other special cards, Set Boosters are the way to go. If you do care about the art cards and special cards, then Collectors should be part of the mix. At some point, if you want a full set, you have to go online and order individual cards. Or, buy a truly stupid number of boxes of both types.

  3. Brian King
    November 26, 2021

    Well, I did it. I fell deep down the MTG rabbit hole. The Forgotten Realms set wasn’t enough. And the amount of money I have spent (including this morning’s Black Friday binge) is absurdly stupid by any definition. If I see you at Winter Fantasy, I’ll tell you all about it, as well as the great rate I got when I refinanced the house to pay for it all! 😮

    • Alphastream
      November 27, 2021

      I mean, it is a time-honored tradition for those of us who have spent too much money on Magic to help others do the same!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This entry was posted on July 8, 2021 by and tagged .


Follow me on

Mastodon logo Mastodon


Follow me on

BlueSky logo BlueSky

Privacy Policy